I watched Saving Private Ryan for
the first time yesterday, which easily exceeded my expectations.
Steven Spielberg is unquestionably at his finest with this film.
However, I believe my impression of the movie is significantly
different than that held by much of the original audience due to the
year of my viewing, over a decade and a half since its
ground-breaking release. The reason for this, I believe, is that I
have grown up in, and experienced the work of, the 'post-SPR
era,' in which many war films are strongly influenced by the path SPR
dictated in the cinematic depiction of combat.
At the time of SPR's
release, critics immediately noted its graphic, realistic depiction
of violence. David Edelstein wrote for Slate:
“What Steven Spielberg has accomplished in Saving Private
Ryan is to make violence
terrible again. Nothing in the movie's melodramatic narrative can
diminish the shocking immediacy of its combat scenes.” He points
out that SPR stood in
stark contrast to the unrealistic “rock-n-roll” combat depictions
of the (my coinage, here) 'pre-SPR
era.' Joe Morgenstern, writing for the Wall Street Journal
at the time, made the same observation: “Saving Private
Ryan. . . puts a new, indelibly
terrible face on war.”
Much of this style comes from
the stunning technical accomplishments of the movie, which scored a
bevy of Oscars for its sound and visual design. The combat shots are
gritty POV work, forcing the audience to watch the humiliating death
throes and animal seizes of American and German soldiers.
While not reducing this
accomplishment, the past decade or so of war films and shows have
cemented this style as standard practice. So, for me, what was
visually shocking in 1998 is now still obscenely difficult to watch,
but not surprising, given such post-SPR
films and shows as: Black Hawk Down,
Flags of our Fathers,
Letters From Iwo Jima,
Band of Brothers, The
Pacific, The Hurt
Locker, etc. While there are
always exceptions, the noticeable shift from the pre-to-post SPR
is from heroic, unrealistic violence to gritty, disturbing, and most
importantly, realistic violence. I think this is a very important and
good breakthrough for American audiences, and Saving
Private Ryan is hugely
responsible.
Again, however, when watching
the film as a viewer in the post-SPR era,
I accepted the visual style and was instead drawn to the moral
questions that Spielberg poses via the travails of Captain John
Miller and his unlucky squad, chosen for a “public relations”
mission to rescue the last surviving Ryan brother in combat. The
mission is ordered at the behest of General George Marshall, who
justifies the perilous efforts required to locate and retrieve the
wayward Ryan with Abraham Lincoln's “Bixby letter,” notifying a
Civil War mother of the death of her five sons in combat, itself a
letter of very deservedly glorified language. Marshall's implication
is that Mrs. Ryan should not have to face the death of all of her
sons as Bixby did, and barks the orders.
Meanwhile, the beleaguered squad
under Miller (Hanks) is left to unravel the issues the mission
involves. The mission itself is to find and bring home Pvt. Ryan of
the 101st
Airborne, who has missed his intended drop location in the Normandy
invasion and is God-knows-where, certainly putting a lot of German
soldiers between himself and Miller's squad. The mission is FUBAR. As
the squad grimly tracks and fights their way to Ryan, they confront
the deaths of two of their men in firefights. “We all have mamas,”
notes a disgruntled private on the verge of desertion. Should two
mothers now be childless so that Mrs. Ryan may, possibly, not be? How
many men have to die for this “asshole”? The ever-staid Miller
sticks to his orders as well as he might, but even he cannot resolve
the question by the end of the movie, and dies having acquiesced to
Ryan's own refusal to obey the order.
This question, of following
orders until the ultimate sacrifice despite dubious terms of
completion, gripped my mind and didn't let go. Personally, a
satisfactory answer doesn't quite exist—I jump between the two
sides of the argument; there is a tension within myself about the
right answer. On one hand, following orders is what keeps our
breathtakingly efficient armed forces on top of their game, and
without respect for the chain of command, our troops are nothing.
However, an unjust law is no law at all, and following a FUBAR order
means making a FUBAR decision. Responsibility cannot be escaped, and
more importantly, neither can the guilt of watching your men die
around you for a cause you doubt yourself. It seems of the sacrifices
demanded by the military is the occasional, sometimes fatal,
inability to exercise one's own good judgement.
Whether Spielberg attempts to
answer this question at the film's resolution or not is itself a
tricky question. Ultimately, most—or all—of Miller's squad,
including Miller, are killed while aiding Ryan's unit in defense of a
crucial bridge. Though Miller's intention was to bring Ryan back
following the defense attempt in case of success, he did disobey
orders by allowing Ryan to engage in a massive firefight, even
jeopardizing his entire rescue squad to aid the bridge defense. So,
did this horrific ending (which Ryan interestingly survives) come
about as a result of the FUBAR mission assignment, or as a result of
Miller's bending the assignment to its breaking point in favor of his
good judgement—that is, to stay and defend the bridge with Ryan?
It's tempting to criticize
Spielberg for whitewashing all of this nuance with the closing scene
of an aged, veteran Ryan and his family at the site of Miller's
Arlington grave. However, Ryan's final words at the grave (for me, at
least) dredge up that unsettling question of some lives weighed
against others. “I brought my family,” says Ryan, hoping aloud
that he has lived his life in a way that deserves the sacrifice of
Miller and his men. It is easy to instead picture Miller and his
entire squad, with their families, visiting a single Arlington grave
site. Rather, the lone Ryan and his family move from headstone to
headstone.
To pretend answers is tempting
but foolish in such a story. Instead, I leave the movie frustrated by
these dilemmas and horrors of war. They are unthinkable, impossible,
terrible questions, and posed unflinchingly by the genius of Steven
Spielberg. 9/10.
Sunday, June 1, 2014
Thursday, May 1, 2014
Book Review: UFOs, by Leslie Kean (2010)
Rating: 5/5 - Go read this book right now!
I like to fancy myself a skeptic; evidence is kind of my thing. If you're going to make a claim, you should back it up. I try to marshal a lot of my own thoughts with the evidence-based approach. For this reason, cracking open Leslie Kean's UFOs today felt like getting hit in the face with a baseball bat - of evidence!
I arrived at this book with probably an average intellectual history on the subject of "Unidentified Flying Objects." At a young age, I was fascinated with - and slightly terrified of - the anecdotal accounts I had read, often featuring artist's embellishments: the lonely couple, driving along a country road before being abducted by a looming, light-filled saucer, manned by slit-eyed aliens at the helm, of course only recall the trauma of ghastly sexual probing while undergoing "hypnosis therapy." Unsurprisingly, it did not take long to shake loose from this dubious (to say the least) material, partially aided by some of the writings of Carl Sagan, who participated in UFO investigations by the US Air Force and asserted in his book, The Demon Haunted World, that "alien abductions" are easily explained by mass hysteria and waking hallucinations.
I became acquainted with other, likely explanations: swamp lights, weather balloons, abnormal weather, navigation lights on planes, crop circle hoaxers, forged photographs. We know the overall Hollywoodization of UFOs as extraterrestrial vessels of all kinds. Basically, pop culture says UFOs = aliens, preferably either really powerful or really goofy ones. (Close Encounters of the Third Kind is still one of my all-time favorite movies, though.) Now, UFOs are the subjects of satirized 50s-horror.
| The somewhat stalled-out facade of UFOs today. |
I think this collection of images and a general dismissal of UFO research to the confines of conspiracy-nut fantasyland is where not only I, but many of us, approach the subject from. It feels like a settled issue. Maybe our society was scared by UFOs for a little bit, in the past, but now we can laugh about it because we know better.
Enter Leslie Kean.
In an interview with MSNBC from 2010, Kean stated that the purpose of her book was to explore the roughly "five percent" of UFO reports that remain unexplained after official investigation. Ninety-five percent of "UFO" (Or "UAP," Unexplained Aerial Phenomena) reports probably fit in to the list of explanations I rattled off above, that is, they can be explained by natural or man-made phenomena.
However, once one starts to wade into the well-documented sea of that remaining, unexplained five percent, the laughter dies down rather quickly. This is the realm of quite shockingly verifiable evidence, not some half-assed campfire story. Some of the most credible UFO events are compilations of hundreds of independently confirmed reports matching in description and location, others are documented by original camera or radar data, and still others are backed by not only the pilots, high-ranking government workers and military officials who reported them, but also the follow-ups: extensive panel investigations that time and again methodically trudge through physical, climatological, psychological, artificial, or other possibilities until again and again arriving at the same startling conclusion: the evidence is detailed and reliable/the photo hasn't been tampered with/the eyewitnesses are credible, and we have no idea what the hell happened on [insert dozens of dates, times, and locations].
The fact of the matter is, a strain of evidence from hundreds of aviation, civilian, and military reports from around the world demonstrate quite convincingly that there is some sort of weird phenomenon taking place in Earth's skies, involving high-speed objects with incredible maneuverability and physics-defying capabilities. That, as it turns out, is not so difficult to establish.
What is difficult to establish is anything beyond this disconcerting realization - What are these things? Are they man-made? How do they work? Where do they come from? Do they pose a threat to us, specifically aviation? The line between fact and fiction is not crossed by acknowledging UFOs; it is crossed when giddily speculating the answers to these questions. (Looking at you, Spielberg).
As it turns out, this societal stigma of associating UFO research with crazy alien people is detrimental to finding out what is actually going on with this well-documented phenomenon. Kean isn't pretending to hold all the answers; she simply gathers up the best data she can find, holds it aloft, and asks, "Can we maybe look into this business?"
That, to me, seems like a reasonable and exciting question.
Thursday, April 3, 2014
The Map
I'm going to kick off my blog's life with an analogy that has been stirring in my head for some time now. I present "The Map":
________
The galley had been stopped at a small port town for only a few days and was still taking on fresh supplies when a wandering stranger sought out the ship's captain in one of the seaside taverns along the harbor. The stranger was seeking passage to the galley's ultimate destination, he explained, and offered funds to be taken aboard for the duration of the journey. The stranger's funds were adequate for the trip, and the captain agreed to take him on, for the stranger presented well and seemed without undesirable tendencies.
After embarkment and a few days at sea, the captain had conversed enough with the stranger to know that the man was fairly interested in navigation and might even have some insights to contribute; whenever course decisions were made by the captain and a few officers, the stranger was always invited in to observe and offer occasional commentary.
It was on one of these occasions that the stranger began to discern differences between the crew's knowledge of the sea and what the captain's map depicted. As the captain and his crew were conversing and marking out the next several days of sailing, the stranger remarked:
"Could not we instead cut directly between these two masses, avoiding the bowed path you are plotting out?" He pointed to the map.
The crew explained to him that the map was actually outdated in this instance, for a shallow reef, unmarked on the map, spanned across the stranger's proposed route, which would ground and capsize the galley if they tried to bear across.
Over the next several weeks of the voyage, the stranger noted several such instances. The map would picture certain landmasses out of place, or depict barriers not actually present, or as in the first example, simply not account for objects clearly present in the route. The stranger noticed that every time the map contained such an error, captain and crew would automatically correct the route without even needing to mention the discrepancy. Ultimately, it became clear that they knew the sea better than the map itself did, and likely could take the voyage without it.
When the stranger voiced his observation, he was surprised by the reaction:
"No, no," said an officer, "every captain on every ship before us has used this map. Its value is incalculable, and to forfeit the knowledge it presents us would be madness."
This seemed to be the pervading attitude regarding the map, which puzzled the stranger but ultimately brought him no harm as far as he could tell; he was safely deposited at his destination when the voyage finally ended and parted ways with the crew on fair terms. In his subsequent wanderings, he would frequently remember the crew and captain of that galley and shake his head with slight confusion.
________
Pilot
Hello, my name is Thomas. I have been posting my opinions regarding politics, science, etc. on Facebook for some time now, but I think this is a better setting in which to share them. I hope you enjoy reading and potentially discussing future posts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

